Best RPG Developer?

Show Topics In:
Posted 5:27am on Sun 23 May 2010
T3KK1T
  • Posts: 1
00
Best RPG Developer?
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.
Posted 7:05am on Sun 23 May 2010
FantasyMeister
  • Posts: 6,147
00
In response to Topic
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.

» Go to T3KK1T's original post
Bethesda is better at open worlds.
Square Enix is better at westernised-JRPGs.
Atlus is better at offline grindfests.
TriAce is better at action-JRPGs.
Blizzard is better at multiplayer.
Bioware is better at emotional engagement.
Level-5 is better at characterisation.
Lionhead is better at casual/comedy.
Rockstar has the greatest potential if it went into the MMORPG genre.

(imho)
Posted 9:20am on Sun 23 May 2010
Mr_Ninjutsu
  • Posts: 8,195
12
In response to FantasyMeister's
Bethesda is better at open worlds.
Square Enix is better at westernised-JRPGs.
Atlus is better at offline grindfests.
TriAce is better at action-JRPGs.
Blizzard is better at multiplayer.
Bioware is better at emotional engagement.
Level-5 is better at characterisation.
Lionhead is better at casual/comedy.
Rockstar has the greatest potential if it went into the MMORPG genre.

(imho)

» Go to FantasyMeister's original post
FM sorry but the last comment about Rockstar is all wrong. Imagine the potential of Pokemon if it went into the MMORPG genre.
Posted 10:37am on Sun 23 May 2010
Woffls
  • Posts: 8,045
00
In response to Topic
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.

» Go to T3KK1T's original post
GameFreak, Bioware, Bethesda.

There's no point comparing Bethesda and Squeenix. They're both flagship developers of their respective sub-genres of the RPG, two which have too many differences to make a comparison worthwhile.
Posted 3:12pm on Sun 23 May 2010
dudester
  • Posts: 4,083
00
In response to Topic
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.

» Go to T3KK1T's original post
And the winner is sports interactive Wink Grin
Posted 3:36pm on Sun 23 May 2010
CheekyLee
  • Posts: 7,260
00
In response to Topic
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.

» Go to T3KK1T's original post
I'd second Woffls in his proclamation that GameFreak stand tallest of all. That being said, my favourite RPGs ever remain the pre-Enix SquareSoft titles Secret of Mana and Vagrant Story. And I would also happily put Climax (Shining Force, Landstalker, etc.) and Nintendo ( Zelda, nuff said) forward for ARPG consideration.
Posted 5:40pm on Sun 23 May 2010
renegade
  • Posts: 2,723
00
In response to Topic
Me and my friend have been arguing over which RPG developer is better: Bethesda or Square Enix. He's a hardcore WoW fan, and isn't in to games that don't have some multiplayer aspect, and also doesn't do much console gaming, so he's not too familiar with this kind of stuff. So, please share your opinion on which is a better game developer. All useful comments are appreciated.

» Go to T3KK1T's original post
Blizzard need to make an RPG in the Warcraft/Starcraft world would be like zomg "drool"
Posted 7:29pm on Sun 23 May 2010
Stegosaurus-Guy-II
  • Posts: 2,463
01
In response to CheekyLee's
I'd second Woffls in his proclamation that GameFreak stand tallest of all. That being said, my favourite RPGs ever remain the pre-Enix SquareSoft titles Secret of Mana and Vagrant Story. And I would also happily put Climax (Shining Force, Landstalker, etc.) and Nintendo ( Zelda, nuff said) forward for ARPG consideration.

» Go to CheekyLee's original post
Good point, Zelda is an amazing RPG but I think Modern Warfare 2 is better. IW make the best RPGs.
Posted 7:43pm on Sun 23 May 2010
bodomhatecrew777
  • Posts: 44
00
In response to Stegosaurus-Guy-II's
Good point, Zelda is an amazing RPG but I think Modern Warfare 2 is better. IW make the best RPGs.

» Go to Stegosaurus-Guy-II's original post
im disagreeing on that fact, i find that IW needs to get better at story telling and not having linear story lines. you can finish MW and MW2 in probably 4 hours each, while Square Enix titles take a lot longer, Zelda takes a lot longer, and Pokemon, if you just beat all the gyms and ***** then its fairly short but to do EVERYTHING, it could take you 200+ hours. (personal experience).
Posted 8:08pm on Sun 23 May 2010
Stegosaurus-Guy-II
  • Posts: 2,463
01
In response to bodomhatecrew777's
im disagreeing on that fact, i find that IW needs to get better at story telling and not having linear story lines. you can finish MW and MW2 in probably 4 hours each, while Square Enix titles take a lot longer, Zelda takes a lot longer, and Pokemon, if you just beat all the gyms and ***** then its fairly short but to do EVERYTHING, it could take you 200+ hours. (personal experience).

» Go to bodomhatecrew777's original post
You may have...um...missed the joke?
Show Topics In:
Quick Reply

Login or register to reply to this topic

Create a new account or login to take part in this topic discussion.
View Full Site